Singing Start Guide
A range test and a pitch meter tell you where your voice is today. Singorama’s 28 guided audio modules (per the vendor’s page) are a structured course for building the voice over time.
Affiliate link: we earn a commission if you buy, at no extra cost to you.
See what’s inside →Singing Carrots and Simply Sing get compared constantly, which is odd, because they are barely the same kind of product. Singing Carrots is a browser toolkit: a vocal range test, pitch exercises, a searchable song database matched to your range. Simply Sing is a polished phone app that plays a backing track and scores how close your voice sits to the melody. One feels like a workshop bench, the other like a game. Which suits you depends almost entirely on whether you enjoy tinkering.
The quick verdict
Singing Carrots gives you more genuinely useful things for nothing, but asks you to be your own teacher and to sit at a computer. Simply Sing gives you less for free and more polish, and it is the one you will actually open on the bus. If your budget is zero and your patience is decent, start with Singing Carrots. If you know you need something that feels good to use or you will quit by week two, start with Simply Sing.
Singing Carrots: the browser workbench
The thing most people arrive for is the vocal range test. You sing down to your lowest comfortable note and up to your highest, the site tracks it, and you get a range written in note names. That number then does real work: the song database lets you filter by songs that sit inside your range, which quietly solves the most common beginner problem of picking material a third too high and blaming your voice.
Around that sit pitch-matching exercises, a pitch monitor that draws your note in real time, and articles on technique. The whole thing runs in a browser tab with microphone permission, so there is nothing to install. It also looks like a tool built by engineers rather than designers, which is either refreshing or off-putting depending on your temperament. Our Singing Carrots review goes through each tool and how much of it stays free.
Simply Sing: the polished song app
Simply Sing comes from the same studio as Simply Piano and Simply Guitar, and it shows. Onboarding is smooth, the pitch line is beautifully readable, and the library leans hard on songs people actually want to sing. You open it, you sing, you see immediately where you drifted. There is very little to configure and almost nothing to learn about the interface itself.
The catch is the paywall. The free tier is limited (check its current terms), and the depth beyond it is still song-focused rather than technique-focused. We break down what you get at each level in our Simply Sing cost guide, and we answer the free-tier question directly in is Simply Sing free.
Side by side
| Feature | Singing Carrots | Simply Sing |
|---|---|---|
| Platform | Browser, any device with a mic | Phone app, iOS and Android |
| Vocal range test | Yes, and it drives everything else | Informal, built into onboarding |
| Song matching by range | Yes, searchable database | Curated suggestions |
| Live pitch feedback | Yes, plain and accurate | Yes, very readable |
| Structured exercises | Several, self-directed | Light warm-ups |
| Free ceiling | Free tools available (check limits) | Limited (check current terms) |
| Feels good to use | Functional, dated | Excellent |
| Best for | Self-starters on a zero budget | People who need momentum |
The free-versus-paid question
This is where the comparison stops being close. Singing Carrots hands a beginner three things at no cost that are worth having:
- A measured vocal range you can write down and re-test in two months.
- A way to find songs that fit that range instead of guessing.
- A live pitch display for drilling intervals without a subscription clock ticking.
Simply Sing’s free tier is more limited (check its current terms) and its model is the paid subscription. That is not a criticism of the product, only of how far it gets you for nothing. If free is a hard requirement, our roundup of free singing apps covers the rest of the field, and free online singing lessons covers the video side.
What neither of them fixes
Both tools measure the same narrow thing: the pitch of the note you produced. Neither one hears that you are lifting your chin on high notes, or that your last two phrases were held together by neck tension. A vocal range test in particular gets over-read. A beginner’s measured range is mostly a measure of current technique, not of some fixed anatomical limit, and it usually grows once breath support improves. Read how to find your vocal range before you treat any number as your ceiling, and know the signs of vocal strain so you do not chase a higher note into trouble.
What we would actually do
Take the Singing Carrots range test on day one and note the two extremes in a notebook. Use its song filter to pick three songs that genuinely sit in your voice. Then, if you want the daily habit to feel like fun rather than homework, add Simply Sing on top for the song practice. Spend the money you did not spend on a second app on a structured course instead. Singorama’s audio modules are a one-off $67 on the vendor’s page (checked 30 September 2026) and, unlike either tool here, are designed to teach the mechanics behind the notes you keep missing (we have not completed the course; see our Singorama review).
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the Singing Carrots range test accurate?
It is accurate about what you sang into the microphone, which is not quite the same as accurate about your voice. Test when warmed up, in a quiet room, and do not push for one extra squeaky note at the top. Re-testing on three separate days and taking the middle result gives you something far more useful than a single reading.
Can I use Singing Carrots on a phone?
Yes, it runs in a mobile browser, but the interface was clearly designed for a bigger screen and the pitch displays are cramped. A laptop or tablet makes the exercises considerably easier to follow.
Which one improves your pitch faster?
Whichever one you use five days a week. The feedback loop is the active ingredient and both provide it. In practice Simply Sing wins on consistency because it lives on your phone, while Singing Carrots wins on the quality of targeted drilling if you sit down and do it properly.
Do I need either of them if I already take lessons?
Not strictly, but a pitch display between lessons is a cheap way to make your practice honest. Ask your teacher which exercises they want measured; drilling the wrong thing accurately is still drilling the wrong thing.
What to Read Next
- Our full Singing Carrots review
- Our full Simply Sing review
- How to find your vocal range properly
- All our singing app coverage
How we reviewed this (updated 16 October 2026): this page is based on the vendor’s official information, pricing and policies and on public user feedback. We have not hands-on tested the products listed.
;padding:10px 14px;margin-top:36px”>⚠️ Affiliate disclosure: some links in this article are affiliate links. If you buy through them we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you — it never changes what we recommend. Read our full disclosure.